Five Questions to Ask Before Your Next School Improvement Plan

Every spring, schools across the country write improvement plans. Most are thoughtful. Many are compliant. And by October, a surprising number are sitting in a shared drive that nobody opens.

I’ve written those plans as a principal, reviewed them as a superintendent, and helped districts rebuild them as a consultant. The plans that work almost never have better goals than the ones that don’t. They have better answers to five questions that get asked before anyone starts writing.

1. What is the data actually telling us, and what is it not?

Most plans start from the state report card, which tells you where students are struggling but rarely why. A drop in reading proficiency could be a curriculum gap, a pacing problem, a grouping problem, or multilingual learners getting content stripped down instead of scaffolded. Each of those needs a different fix.

Before you set a goal, spend time in classrooms and look at student work. Write down what the data can’t explain. Those questions are often where the real work lives.

2. What are we going to stop doing?

This is the question almost nobody asks. Teachers and leaders already have full plates, and a plan that only adds is a plan that won’t be followed.

When Southern Wake Academy moved from a D to a C in a single semester, there was no miracle program. The adults got aligned on what mattered most and stopped doing everything else. Name two or three things you’ll set down so the new work has room to breathe.

3. Who owns each piece, by name?

“The leadership team will monitor” is not ownership. Every strategy in your plan needs a person whose name is attached to it, and that person needs the time and authority to move it.

If you can’t name the owner, the strategy isn’t ready to go in the plan yet.

4. What will we look at every two weeks?

Annual goals are important, but you can’t steer by a number that arrives once a year. Pick one or two leading indicators per goal that you can see quickly: walk-through data, common assessment results, attendance for a target group, the share of IEPs meeting quality checks.

Then put the review on the calendar before the school year starts. A plan without a review routine is a document. A plan with one is a mechanism.

5. What will we do when it isn’t working?

Something in your plan won’t work the way you expect. That isn’t failure; that’s how improvement works. The difference is whether you decided in advance how you’ll respond.

Agree now on what “off track” looks like for each goal and what the first adjustment will be: more coaching, a schedule change, a narrower focus. Teams that plan for the middle of the year handle it calmly. Teams that don’t tend to quietly abandon the plan.

Where to start

If you’re heading into a planning season, try this: bring your leadership team together and spend one meeting on these five questions before anyone opens the plan template. You’ll write a shorter plan, and you’ll use it.

At Studiously, this is the thinking behind Groundwork, our needs assessment and improvement planning framework. Your team rates itself against clear indicators, we check those ratings against evidence, and together we pick the two or three changes that matter most. If you’d like a quick place to start, our free Groundwork Quick Check is ten statements your team can rate in one sitting.

Which of these five questions does your team skip most often? I’d love to hear what’s worked in your school or district.

Dr. Amy Davis is the founder and CEO of Studiously and a former principal and charter school superintendent.

Next
Next

What a Principal’s First 90 Days Should Look Like